Four recommendations are required
St. Paul's School's application checklist lists these recommendation forms, all submitted through the Gateway to Prep Schools application.
- Current English Teacher Recommendation
- Current Math Teacher Recommendation
- Personal Recommendation
- Principal/Counselor Recommendation
A Special Interest Recommendation is listed as optional. The checklist also asks for current grades, a transcript covering the previous two years, a copy of standardized test results and a graded writing sample.
The English, math and counselor forms need current people
The application FAQ answers a common question directly. It says "the math, English and counselor recommendation forms must be completed by current teachers." Teachers from the prior year can't fill those in.
There's one exception for schools that run block schedules. The FAQ says that if your child hasn't yet had one of those classes, "we can accept history or science."
Teachers from prior years are welcome to complete the Personal or Special Interest recommendations. So a teacher who knew your child well last year but doesn't teach them now fits the Personal or Special Interest form.
Who writes the personal letter
St. Paul's pages don't say who should write the Personal Recommendation, other than that prior-year teachers are welcome to. A sensible approach is to pick someone who has watched your child work over time and can describe them concretely. Your child should ask in person before anyone receives a Gateway email.
Grades and transcripts
The checklist wants current grades and a transcript from the previous two years. The FAQ deals with the case that trips up many families. If your child's school hasn't issued semester grades by January 15, the school should send what is available. You then email admissions@sps.edu to say when the rest will arrive, so the office can note it in the file.
That's practical guidance from the school. It means a late report card doesn't have to stop you from submitting. It does mean you owe the admission office an email.
Standardized test scores follow a different route. St. Paul's lists SSAT code 6886 and ISEE code 300110. ACT, PSAT and SAT results are emailed to admissions@sps.edu. The page also says that for state standardized testing, "Have your school upload them with your transcripts." So a state test report can travel with the transcript, which is a reason to ask your child's school office early how it sends records. All tests must be taken within one year of the application deadline. The FAQ says St. Paul's prefers scores before January 15, but a student who retakes a test in January can send those results and the school will consider them.
Asking teachers in a sensible order
St. Paul's asks for Part 1 of the Gateway application, the Candidate Profile, before an interview is booked, and its step list says to submit the profile well before the application deadline. Because the English and math forms must come from current teachers, those requests fit best in the fall, once your child has started the year.
A good request is specific. Tell the teacher the deadline, that St. Paul's uses Gateway, and which form you mean. A teacher who knows exactly what is being asked can answer faster.
Who to contact
The admissions pages list admissions@sps.edu for application questions, along with phone lines at 1-888-644-9611 and 1-603-229-4700. Use them for the questions the pages leave open, such as how to handle a school that doesn't send records electronically or what to do when a recommender is travelling near the deadline. Keep any reply you receive with your application records.
Interview and recommendations run on separate tracks
The interview needs Part 1 of the Gateway application first, and the school offers campus interviews from June through January and virtual interviews from September through January. Recommendations don't wait for the interview. A family can have the teacher requests out while the interview is still being booked, which spreads the work across the fall instead of piling it into December.
What isn't published, and the deadline
St. Paul's pages don't publish the questions on its recommendation forms, a recommended length, or how recommendations are weighed against grades and testing.
St. Paul's admissions page lists January 15 as the due date for completed application and financial aid documents in the 2027-28 application cycle, and Gateway's St. Paul's listing shows January 15, 2027 for fall 2027 entry. The guide to St. Paul's admissions timeline for 2027-28 entry shows the full sequence.
Use the free application planner to map out the steps, and see preparation options when you're ready.